On this page
Map the workflow before the shortlist
Write down the current workflow, the step that is slow, and the person who owns the output. “Use AI for marketing” is not a workflow. “Turn a research brief into three campaign variants for review by Thursday” is.
Then decide where the tool sits: in the editor, in the meeting, in the pull request, or across a repository. Tools that sit in the same place are easier to compare and easier to remove later.
Price the whole seat, not the sticker
The entry price is rarely the cost. Add seats, usage metering, storage, admin controls and any add-on needed to make the tool usable by the team. A cheap per-user plan can become expensive when the whole department needs access.
Ask what happens when the usage cap is reached: does the tool stop, degrade, or bill overage? Ask whether the trial converts automatically and what notice is required to cancel.
Check data handling and admin controls
- Retention: how long are prompts, uploads and outputs stored, and can an admin delete them?
- Training: is company content used to train models? Is there a contractual opt-out?
- Access: are SSO, role-based permissions, audit logs and offboarding available on the plan you are buying?
- Residency: does the vendor store data in a region your policy requires?
- Subprocessors: which third parties touch the data, and is there a current list?
Run a bounded trial
Give the trial one workflow, one owner and one success measure. A useful measure is “time from brief to reviewed draft” or “number of pull requests reviewed without rework”, not “team sentiment after the demo”.
Set a stop date and a decision meeting before the trial begins. At the end, compare the finalists on the same fields. If the tool did not change the workflow, it is not a fit yet.
Compare finalists on the same fields
Use a small, fixed set of fields: entry price for the required seats, free or trial limits, platforms, integrations, admin controls, data terms and export. Score each finalist against the same brief.
Keep the comparison link with the procurement notes so the decision is reproducible. A year later, the useful question will be what changed, not what the demo looked like.
Common questions
What should a business check before buying an AI tool?
Start with the workflow, the total seat cost and data handling. Confirm retention, training use, admin controls, integrations and what happens at the usage cap before the trial begins.
Is a free trial enough to evaluate an AI tool?
A trial is enough if it covers the real workflow and the plan you would buy. Give it an owner, a success measure and a stop date, then compare the finalists on the same fields.
How many AI tools should a team start with?
Start with one tool for one repeated workflow. Add another only when a specific job is not covered. Fewer tools are easier to secure, train and remove.